A brutal storm raged off the north coast of Wales on the morning of Sunday, January 4, 1857 and three ships were floundering in the roiling sea. At 10 am, the Point of Ayr lifeboat was launched to go to the aid of the ship Temperance.
In the 1800s, lifeboat stations had been formed at Liverpool and Hoylake, staffed with men who could reach a wreck regardless of the direction of wind or sea. At Point of Ayr, however, there was a lack of skilled rescue men. Their crew was composed mainly of local tradesmen, gardeners and miners. To complement this group of volunteers, two fishermen were sent over from Hoylake — Robert Beck as captain, and John Sherlock as mate. They were provided with housing and an allowance that could be supplemented by the sale of any fishing catch. It was a meagre life.
lighthouse at Point of Ayr
The lifeboats supplied to the crew at Point of Ayr were 42 ft. clinker built boats similar to a ship’s boat intended for either rowing or sailing. When rowing, they pulled 10 oars. Under sail, they had two fixed sails and a foresail. Buoyancy was provided by air cases under the thwarts and a large cork fender around the outside of the boat. Total crew was 13 men.
men and horses pulling lifeboat from the sea
As the lifeboat launched that morning of Jan 4, onlookers watched from the shore. Off the coast of Rhyl, the stormy sea caught and overturned the lifeboat. None of the men on board were wearing lifejackets as they were made of cork at the time and the men found they hampered their movement in times of rescue. Three men were seen clinging to the overturned keel of the Point of Ayr lifeboat. After half an hour, though, the raging sea took them under.
The crew on this unfortunate occasion was composed of three miners, three labourers, two gardeners, a shopkeeper, coachman, and sawyer in addition to Robert Beck and John Sherlock. All 13 men perished that day.
A public subscription was opened for the dependents of the lost men. It was liberally subscribed to, reaching the total of £3,025.19s. This was more than enough to meet the demands and the balance was held to meet the needs of other sufferers. The Dock Board held an inquiry into the matter. The boat was recovered and carefully examined but found to be in good condition. One thing that did come out of the tragedy was a tightening of the rules about wearing lifejackets. A fine was imposed for not wearing them. In addition, fixed sails on lifeboats were no longer permitted.
John Jones Sherlock, b 23 Sep 1804 in West Kirby, Cheshire, England; d 7 Jan 1857 in Point of Ayr lifeboat disaster was my husband’s first cousin 6x removed. Left to mourn his death were his wife, Sarah (nee Williams), his parents Joseph and Margaret, and 8 siblings: Anne, Mary, Margaret, Thomas, Richard, Joseph, Peter and Jane, as well as 42 nieces and nephews.
WeGoBack 
My wife’s family are related to Robert Beck
Nice to ‘meet’ you, clawfish. Your wife has a real hero in her family tree.
Her Auntie lives in Edmonton and has done the genealogy going back to the 1500’s and the Sherlocks are related which is interesting, we live in West Kirby
It seems like there were many family connections between the fisher families of Hoylake and West Kirby. My husband has Jones, Hughes, Eccles and Sherlock families that all link into his family tree.
John Jones Sherlock is my 1st cousin X 5 times removed his mother was my 5x great aunt on my paternal grandmothers tree, and many of the other crew men’s names are also in my tree, will have to research and see if any others are near or far relations.
Very interesting post thank you
John Jones SHERLOCK is my first cousin 4 times removed. His grand-aunt Mary SHERLOCK (b1746 Raby) married John EVANS of Puddington on 29 April 1766 in Upton-in-Overchurch St Mary.
I passed by the church at Llansa recently and found the memorial on the wall. I am wondering if there are extant burials related to this incident in the now overgrown graveyard, if so I will take another look when I go that way again to my daughter in Prestatyn.
I would welcome any information on the Schooner TEMPEANCE that the men had gone to the aid of on that day. LR for 1856/1857 shows one TEMPERANCE a sailing schooner, Master J Gosling, 113 tons, built Falmouth 1850, owned by T Coad, at Truro, classified as 5A1, iron bolted and zinc covered below water line 1854.
Chris Roche http://www.capehorners.org
mariner@chrisroche.co.uk
Robert Beck was my great, great, great grand father. I don’t know his wife’s name but they had a son Thomas who married Ann Jones and they had seven children. Their son William married Ann? and they had seven children, Daughter Sarah Anne married Walter Edwards, and they had twins Frances and Mabel. Mabel was my mother.
Robert Beck’s grandson William was a fisherman. I have a certificate from the Liverpool Shipwreck and Humane Society. 5 pounds was awarded to William Beck Master and 3 crew of the Hoylake trawler “Stag” for having with great difficulty and risk, rescued the Master and three man crew of the schooner “Ann” 30th January 1890.
My grand father Walter Edwards was a plumber and was drowned in Durban Bay South Africa.
I have what I believe is a copy of an article from the Liverpool Echo
titled The Beck Family. The Memorial to Robert Beck. It tells the story of the disaster almost word for word to the one above.
At the bottom it says. This is the story behind the simple memorial to Robert Beck in Hoylake Church. It does not say which church. It was written by D.P.Branigan 5 Cholmondeley Road, West Kirby
My understanding is that the Thomas Beck (b1818 Hoose Cheshire) who married Ann Jones (b1819 Mostyn Flintshire) was baptised on 3 April 1818 in West Kirby St Bridget’s Church as a son of Thomas Beck (b1790 Kendal Westmorland) and Jane Little (b1793 Little Meols Cheshire) who married on 10 July 1811 in Liverpool St Nicholas.
After Thomas senior’s early death in 1819 (aged 29) his widow Jane married Robert Beck (b1799 Kendal Westmorland) on 13 March 1822 in Liverpool St Peter.
Thomas (b1790) and Robert (1799) are believed to have been brothers, both sons of Robert Beck and Dolly Bamforth who married on 28 January 1783 in Kendal Westmorland.
PS. I have a grand-uncle William Campbell Evans (b1857 London) who emigrated to South Africa in the late 1800’s and was proprietor of a Temperance Hotel in Durban until his death there in 1940.